In October 2020 I took a scenic drive from Cheboygan to Lowell and came upon this exhibit on M-33 between Fairview and Comins, Michigan. I was curious about this display. I safely pulled over and strode up the hill for a closer look-see.
I navigated the slope carefully as I was alone and orthopedic surgeries have become a unique ‘hobby’ for me. I wondered who had set up this mausoleum of sorts. ‘Oh dear,’ I thought, ‘was there a tragedy involving children?’ My mind raced thinking of the children I have known who have passed away. As an elementary teacher, I have known too many youngsters who live in Heaven. Would someone do THIS to honor a child?
I decided this couldn’t be a shrine to honor a child who had passed. Was this a prank? The horror films I’d seen with my friend Jennifer flicked through my mind. Would this be a testimonial to one of those movies? Which one?
What’s the meaning behind this array? How long had this been here?
When I returned home I searched Facebook and requested to join a group from the area, “What’s Up In Mio, Fairview, Luzerne, Comins” which has over 2,700 members. Surely someone would know the story behind this. I posted one photo and asked, “Can anyone tell me how the doll hill got started?”
Responses varied from eager art lovers intrigued and supportive of this cluster of figurines to ‘creepy,’ ‘garbage’ and ‘sad.’ Some speculated that a graduating class started this. Others recalled two desks being left in the ditch and then dolls started appearing on the hill. One man said he lived across the street and it had been there a long time. Someone else posted about there being a ‘shoe tree’ that had been cut down. One woman stated firmly that this wasn’t the doll hill from M-33. Many people replied to other’s comments. Opinions were flying throughout the 80 comments.
Finally, two individuals shared that the owner of the property started the doll display. “He even cleans it up from time to time.” I was intrigued! I HAD to talk with this person and learn the true meaning of this exhibit.
I messaged both members of the page asking for the name of the property owner. One person responded and I went to work investigating contact information. I found a phone number of the ‘age-experienced’ gentleman. I called and left a message. As I hung up I realized that this could be the end of the road if he wasn’t willing to return my call. I may never know about this curious arrangement. I sighed with disappointment and shrugged at our dog, Shackleton. (He is always at my heels.)
As I relaxed on the couch that evening, my phone rang. I didn’t recognize the number and quickly assumed that it probably had to do with my car warranty. “Hello?” I answered. A solemn voice responded to my greeting. “You called about the dolls on the hill?” “Oh my gosh! Thank you for calling me back! I am so curious about dolls collection!” I rolled off the couch and hustled to my bedroom office so I could take notes.
“I stated it about ten years ago.” he explained. (The gentleman asked me to keep his identity anonymous.) “I had a few dolls and people just keep adding more. Last fall someone added some nasty ones. I suppose it was for Halloween, but I took them down.” We agreed that it was an interesting conversation starter. I shared that my Facebook post proved that!
“Do you know the author, Johnathan Rand?” he inquired. I did. As an elementary teacher I was familiar with his “Nightmare Nation” books. I learned that Johnathan Rand is one of Chris Wright’s pen names. Chris has written the Michigan Chillers series (18 books) and the American Chillers series. “Well, he was here and based one of his books, “Village of the Dolls,” on my doll hill.” I could hear the smile broaden his face. “Village of the Dolls” is the first book in the Nightmare Nation series.
Surrounding Mio Michigan has other sights, too. There’s an Indian head made from limestone rock.
Tom Moran of Moran Iron Works usually creates sculpture using steel. This limestone Indian Head was modeled after Ohio’s Chief Leatherlips statue. It now sits at the entrance of the Skyline Event Center.
When I asked the young gal about the pink elephant after ordering a submarine sandwich, she raised her painted on eyebrows and shrugged. It’s been here a long time.
As I turned west to head home to Lowell, I was startled by this shrine next to the Catholic church. I was completely in awe. This European style shrine had candle filled grottos in remembrance of the apparitions of Mary. Below is the link to the piece I’ve written about this marvel.
Michigan is full of small wonders located on the backroads. With a few inquisitive questions one can learn the source of these small town mysteries which have captivated many travelers. Keep your eyes open for similar findings along your routes in life. Enjoy!
21 thoughts on “Creepy Doll Hill”
I live in Comins and really enjoyed your article. I never knew all that about the shrine.
The shrine is incredible. I enjoyed many places in your area including the damn, too. Thank you for your feedback.
I am the person who thought the dolls did not look like the ones on M33. I have looked at the other pictures you put up and can say that I was wrong. It looks so much different from the road, I enjoyed your story about the area. I am sorry for my arrogance, and hope you will accept my apology. Thank you for highlighting our county.
No worries! I enjoyed traveling through and highlighting your area. Happy New Year!
It’s funny you should call it the creepy doll hill, we have always called it that. We have past it for years going up to our summer home near Atlanta Michigan. We have watched it grow. We never knew the story behind it we just thought it was teenagers having fun. It was interesting to hear the story behind it. Yes there was a shoe tree, it was there long before the creepy doll hill but alas it is gone. The two desks are still there in a small valley off the side of the road & there used to be a high chair with a creepy doll sitting in it just down the road from the creepy doll hill. I did enjoy reading your article.
Thank you for your feedback, Joyce! I appreciate you taking the time to comment.
Awsome., you found all that just comming home, wow thats incredible!
I’m glad that you were able to see the unique display.
That blue V8 Jeep is only running on 7!!
Back when I was a kid living in Topinabee, I’d hit Hoppie’s Restaurant on Burt Lake for a burger and fries. Our favorite server was actually part of the family that owned Hoppie’s at the time. Her nickname was “Boots” and she was always smiling. Years later, Boots would find a nice author named Chris Wright to marry. They live in a nice place on a hill on the south end of Topinabee overlooking Mullett Lake. Chris and Boots have been down for cocktail hour a few times, nice people, great books!
Have you folks ever thought of writing a book? I love your adventures, and the history you share about them.
Thank you, Judy. That’s a great idea! The Lowell Ledger has started publishing some articles. 😊
Can you find out why everything was recently removed from Creepy Doll Hill? Loved seeing this when we go north to a retreat in Atlanta, MI, but noticed it was gone in late April. Really missed seeing it.
I will pursue some answers to this mystery.
Did you ever find out why things were removed? My friends and I miss it! We go by there on our way to a retreat in Atlanta several times a year, and always looked for it to see if we could see anything new!
Most people agreed that it was the local government who cleared the dolls from the hill. I have left messages, but I haven’t received any response from local officials.
Did you ever find out why things were removed?? We miss it!
Most people agreed that the local government had the dolls removed. I had called and left messages, but didn’t receive a response.
The pink Elephant has been there since the 60s, it has moved back and forth a couple times as operations changed. Interesting is just north of indian river is the american chillers bookstore.
I can’t believe I have never heard of creepy doll Hill. We have a cabin in Grayling and have traveled that way many times. I really enjoyed your story about them and wish I could have seen them.
The doll hill hasn’t been there that long maybe 5 yrs. They use to put just odds and ends. Before that they tried copying the shoe tree from the south ( that was planted an as ppl grew up they put shoes on it) these people just go to free places and collect things to put there so people will mention the place for attention. The reason the shoe tree was cut down as police told them to. They started throwing them on the power line. It would be nice if they put things there that look good. But the man is and still does put gore and just garbage so people talk. Can’t blame the kids as it was like that quiet sometime before Halloween. I’ve lived here 30 years and the family there hasn’t been here a long time. They even had a doll sitting on a toilet and one with it’s head stuck in it like drowning. That was comes
Terry,
You’re right! Shortly after talking with the owner and writing the article, the dolls (and toilet and toys) had been removed. Chuck and I are curious and enjoy finding fascinating stories around the Great Lakes.
Martha